THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Carthage, MO - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated June 2024 (2024)

“Circle E Country Market is a store that offers a wide variety of fresh, daily-made food and unique prepackaged items. Customers can find wonderful options such as day-old breads at half off and delicious cinnamon rolls. The market is known for its delicious sandwiches, which are piled high with toppings and very popular among hungry groups. The staff is fast, friendly, and courteous, making it a local favorite. Additionally, the market offers affordable prices, like $3 for walnuts, and a helpful team that makes customers feel welcome.”

Customers` Favorites

“Whisler's Drive-Up is a beloved burger joint that has captured the hearts of many. This nostalgic spot serves up classic, old-school burgers that are perfectly greasy and cheesy. The simple menu boasts made-to-order goodness, with fan favorites like the double cheeseburger and the Farmer Burger, featuring fresh pickles, red onion, ham, bacon, and cheese. Whether you're a local or willing to drive an hour, Whisler's is a must-stop destination that packs well for takeout and travels well, making it a consistent and delightful experience for all who visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Taqueria Los Compas is a highly recommended Mexican restaurant, known for its authentic and phenomenal food. Favorites include carnitas, carne asada, al pastor, quesabirria, and tortas. The carne asada and refried beans are particularly praised, while the birria tacos are considered some of the best in the 4-state area. The soft Mexican-style rice, lettuce salad, and steak are also highly regarded. While the tortillas could be better, the variety of sauces adds a nice touch.”

Customers` Favorites

“Mis Arcos Mexican Restaurant is a popular dining spot known for its delicious food and friendly service. The menu offers a variety of options, including the highly recommended Nachos Mis Arcos and Mis Arcos plate. The restaurant also features a buffet with an extensive selection. The staff, such as the notable waiter Freddy, provide excellent service. The portions are generous, offering great value for the quality of the food. It's a place where you can enjoy delicious Mexican cuisine and a great dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sirloin Stockade is a family-oriented restaurant known for its world-class dining experience and exceptional service, provided by a waitress with a wonderful personality. The restaurant offers vegetarian options at the salad bar and is kid-friendly, with a variety of great food and desserts for children. The restaurant maintains a mom-and-pop vibe and serves fresh and flavorful steaks. Although there was a misunderstanding about the order, leading to a feeling of being overcharged, the staff's politeness and welcoming attitude made up for it. The buffet items are always kept full and fresh, making it a great value for the price.”

Customers` Favorites

“Habaneros Mexican Grill offers amazing fresh and authentic Mexican food, with excellent service and impeccable dishes. The restaurant is praised for its fast and friendly service, clean environment, and great value. Customers particularly enjoy the well-seasoned and flavorful chicken dishes. Overall, Habaneros Mexican Grill is a popular choice for a delightful Mexican dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Lucky J Steakhouse & Arena is a well-regarded restaurant known for its delicious steaks, including filet and shiskabob, which are cooked to perfection. The restaurant also offers a variety of other mouth-watering dishes, such as loaded baked potatoes, mashed potatoes, cheese curds, and burgers. The shrimp skewers are also a standout, with some reviewers raving about their quality. The service is friendly and attentive, with staff willing to go the extra mile to ensure a positive dining experience. Parking is convenient and plentiful. With a wide range of menu options to suit every taste, Lucky J Steakhouse & Arena is a great choice for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Murphy's Law Restaurant and Bar is a revitalized establishment offering a friendly atmosphere, complete with karaoke and pool-playing regulars. The food is praised for its quality, and the bar area is notably clean. Despite its unassuming exterior, it's considered a hidden gem.”

Customers` Favorites

“Taste of Italy is a casual dining restaurant with a spacious atmosphere. The food is amazing, with authentic Italian dishes like Royal Sea-bass and tortolini, and delicious sides like house dressing salads. The chef is hospitable and welcoming. While it may not be fancy, it's a wonderful family-style restaurant with a great atmosphere. Be patient with the service, especially when busy, and don't forget to bring your own wine. Overall, it's a highly recommended spot that's easy to love.”

Customers` Favorites

“5911 Dhaba serves the best authentic Indian food, made with passion and care. The owners are kind-hearted and driven to provide quality food, often surprising customers with new dishes. The menu items are well-executed, flavorful, and true to Indian traditions. This restaurant is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious Indian cuisine, and its wonderful owners make it a standout in the area.”

Customers` Favorites

“Carthage Family Restaurant offers a variety of meals, including breakfast options that some find a bit pricey. Despite the increasing prices, customers still appreciate the hometown feel and the attentive service provided by friendly waitresses. The menu is extensive, and the food is cooked to order, ensuring a great dining experience. This old-time diner is a favorite meeting spot for groups, with reasonable prices for delicious meals that keep customers coming back for more.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sappiamo Pizza serves high-quality pies with a passion for detail. The crust is cooked to perfection, and the sauce is sweet and well-balanced. The toppings are generous and made with high-quality meats. The classic Margherita pizza is a standout option. The restaurant also offers custom deep dish orders and thin crust options. Reviewers praise the value for money, with generous portions and quality ingredients. The homemade crust and meats are notable highlights. Overall, Sappiamo Pizza is a great choice for those seeking a delicious and competitive-priced meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Roscoe's Bar & Grill is a hidden gem that offers a lively atmosphere with live music, karaoke, and attentive service. The grill provides customized vegan options and serves delectable dishes like the Boudin appetizer and large Catfish filet. Customers praise the clean bathrooms, good beer prices, and friendly bartender, making it a welcoming establishment for all.”

Customers` Favorites

“Boomers BBQ and Catering serves mouth-watering food that exceeds expectations. Their two-can-eat rib dinner with four sides is a highlight, and their BBQ, cheese curds, and brisket with onion rings are all delicious. The friendly and helpful staff ensure a great experience, and the restaurant is kid-friendly and popular among locals.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Carthage Deli is a unique eatery with a quirky atmosphere, featuring pink chairs, old petrol dispensers, and vintage road signs. The menu offers a range of options, including sandwiches, soups, and salads. Reviewers praised the friendly service and economical prices. Standout dishes include the Reuben sandwich and the French dip and turkey pesto.”

Customers` Favorites

“Maple Leaf Coffeehouse & Smootherie is a friendly, locally-owned spot with amazing food and drinks. The Berry Mango Smoothie Bowl and Kale salad w/Chicken are delicious. The staff is welcoming and treats you like family. Despite being busy, they handle everything well and serve in a timely manner. A great place for a nice breakfast or brunch, highly recommended and worth a visit!”

Customers` Favorites

“Apple Road Farm is a highly recommended destination for delicious and beautifully crafted cakes. The farm's owner is known for her prompt responses, flexibility, and attention to detail. From wedding cakes to custom orders, Apple Road Farm delivers exceptional results, exceeding customer expectations with both taste and presentation.”

Customers` Favorites

“Tropical Smoothie Cafe offers friendly service and tasty smoothies. While prices may be slightly higher, the staff is always upbeat and positive, greeting customers with a smile. The cafe supports local causes, including a local high school. Reviews praise the cafe's refreshing drinks and catering services, with some noting slow service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Amigo's Tex Mex is a pleasant dining spot that offers a clean and welcoming atmosphere. The staff is friendly and attentive, with some employees deserving special recognition for their excellent service. The restaurant serves delicious food, including a standout bean burrito sauce, and is reasonably priced. Overall, Amigo's Tex Mex is a great choice for a satisfying meal.”

“This is a wonderful activity to do with family and friends……. There is always so much to choose from with the food options”

Customers` Favorites

“Alim Hibachi Grill and Sushi Japanese Express offers an exceptional dining experience. The restaurant's menu features a variety of delectable options, including hibachi chicken, spring rolls, chicken egg rolls, and sushi rolls. Customers praise the generous portions, with one reviewer able to enjoy their meal for two days. The staff is described as polite and sweet, even providing water and ice for the reviewer's dogs. Overall, Alim Hibachi Grill and Sushi Japanese Express is a favorite among the local community, delivering amazing food and exceptional customer service.”

Customers` Favorites

“I have been here twice on my way from Kansas to Missouri, and both times, the food and baked goods have been wonderful. I also like the radio station that's always on.”

Customers` Favorites

“A wonderful place to eat, stopped in there today for the first time with family and the food was wonderful, will definitely be back”

Customers` Favorites

“Pancake Hut offers good food at fair prices, with generous portions. Located on Historic Route 66, it provides classic diner fare in a small town cafe atmosphere. Customers highly recommend trying the country fried steak. The restaurant has everything you want in a breakfast joint - delicious food, reasonable prices, and excellent service. Vegetarian options are available, and they ensure meatless menu items are prepared separately. Additionally, Pancake Hut is wheelchair accessible, with easy access to doorways and parking.”

Customers` Favorites

“Scooter's Coffee is a highly regarded restaurant, known for its pleasant atmosphere and efficient service. Customers appreciate the friendly and cheerful staff, who make each visit enjoyable. The Sugar Cookie Latte, specifically, is a popular choice and is described as better than Christmas Day. The restaurant also offers a variety of refreshing smoothies, such as the strawberry and peach options, as well as unique blended drinks like the peanut butter beverage. Scooter's Coffee is praised for its affordable prices and prompt service, making it a popular choice for a quick pick-me-up or a family visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Great little Taqueria conveniently located near the town square in Carthage. Authentic dishes, great flavor, and excellent portion size. Chips and salsa were great! If you are looking for authentic food in a quaint and friendly place, then be sure and stop by!”

“La Playita Restaurant in Jasper County is a rare find serving authentic Salvadoran cuisine. Their pupusas are a standout, reminiscent of those from California. The friendly ladies running the restaurant add to the welcoming atmosphere. Cash-only policy is a minor inconvenience, easily overlooked for the delicious food and warm service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Big Ben's BBQ Station offers a unique dining experience, blending fast food and sit-down comfort. The decor is notable, showcasing a passion for Chevy fans. The menu features a variety of options, including pulled chicken, burnt ends, and sandwiches. Reviewers praise the kids' menu, including strips and macaroni, and enjoy the fries and fried mushrooms. The chopped Brisket sandwich receives mixed reviews, with some finding it mediocre in taste and greasy. The facility is clean and comfortable, with accessible seating and a ramp for wheelchairs.”

Customers` Favorites

“El Charro offers a variety of dishes, from the flavorful Estey Felis to the popular choripollo. Despite occasional dry meat, the service impresses even during busy times, as seen with a large group after a funeral. The Sunday lunch service was quick and attentive, with delicious fajitas and burritos for the kids. A great stop for a road trip meal.”

“Taco 66 is a family-owned food truck with big flavors and wonderful prices. They offer dishes like carne asada tacos and carne asada big burrito. The meat quality is good, but some tacos may need extra sauce. The homemade tortillas are fresh, and the friendly staff ensures a pleasant experience. Located in the Forest Park church parking lot, it's a great way to support a local Christian family. Remember to bring cash for tips since card payments don't have a tipping option. Overall, Taco 66 offers flavorful, healthy options at fair prices.”

Customers` Favorites

“Iggy's Diner is a retro-style eatery that serves great food, including their popular chili, in a clean and friendly atmosphere. The diner's staff is welcoming, and the restaurant has a nostalgic 1960s vibe. While some customers have enjoyed their meals, such as the catfish with sides, others have been disappointed with certain dishes, like the mashed potatoes and onion rings. Despite some inconsistencies, Iggy's remains a beloved spot for many, although its early closing hours can be a drawback for some families.”

Customers` Favorites

“Taco Town is a family favorite, with a delicious Taco Salad and unique cheese dip that keeps customers coming back. They offer "puffy tacos" with ground beef, and despite the simple appearance, the food is excellent. The bean dip is a standout, and menu items like the taco burger, bean burrito, and combo burrito are highly recommended. The friendly staff and clean kitchen create a welcoming atmosphere that shouldn't be judged by the restaurant's exterior. Give Taco Town a try for a satisfying meal experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“China Taste is an Americanized Chinese restaurant that offers delectable dishes such as general chicken and orange chicken, praised for their delicious flavors. Despite the unimpressive interior, the food is considered exceptional, with generous portions and affordable prices. The attentive service and wide-ranging menu make China Taste a popular choice among locals and visitors alike.”

Customers` Favorites

“Arby's is a popular fast food restaurant known for its roast beef sandwiches and cruly fries. While service can be slow at times, the staff is generally friendly and professional. The roast beef sandwiches are a highlight, although there may be occasional issues with temperature or condiments. The fries are consistently hot and flavorful. Despite some minor hiccups, Arby's remains a reliable choice for a quick and satisfying meal.”